CHAPTER 7
Pain.
That was the first thing Kaitlyn registered when consciousness returned—a throbbing ache at the base of her skull that pulsed in time with her heartbeat. She tried to open her eyes, but the light stabbed through her retinas like needles.
What happened?
She was lying on cold tile. The convenience store. She'd been in the convenience store.
Ricky.
The memory hit her like a physical blow. Ricky on the floor, throat cut, blood everywhere. And someone standing over him. Someone holding a knife.
Someone whose face she'd seen.
Kaitlyn forced her eyes open, squinting against the harsh emergency lighting. She was still in the convenience store, but she'd been moved—dragged away from the entrance and left near the back wall, partially hidden behind a collapsed shelf.
Her head swam as she tried to sit up. The world tilted sickeningly, and she had to close her eyes again, breathing slowly through her nose until the nausea passed.
Who was it?
She'd seen their face. She knew she had. But when she tried to recall the image, it slipped away like water through her fingers. A blur. A shadow. Features that refused to coalesce into anything recognizable.
Think. Think!
But the harder she tried to remember, the more the memory fragmented. Had it been a man? A woman? Tall? Short? The knife had been large—she remembered that much. A kitchen knife, the blade gleaming with Ricky's blood.
And the smile. She remembered the smile.
Cold. Satisfied. Like they'd been waiting for this moment.
But whose smile?
Kaitlyn pressed her palms against her eyes, trying to force the memory into focus. Nothing. Just darkness and pain and the terrible certainty that she'd seen something important, something crucial, and now it was gone.
They hit me from behind, she realized. Someone else was there. Someone who knocked me out before I could—
Before she could what? Scream? Run? Fight?
It didn't matter. She was alive. That was what mattered.
For now.
Kaitlyn forced herself to stand, using the wall for support. Her legs felt like rubber, and the room spun lazily around her. She took a few experimental steps, testing her balance.
The convenience store was empty except for Ricky's body.
She couldn't look at him. Couldn't bear to see what had been done to him. Instead, she focused on the door, on getting out, on finding the others.
How long was I unconscious?
The emergency lighting was still on, which meant it was still night. But how much of the night had passed? An hour? Two? More?
She stumbled toward the door, her footsteps unsteady. The mall corridor beyond was dark and silent. No sounds of movement. No voices.
Just the endless drip of water from somewhere in the distance.
Kaitlyn made her way toward the foyer, one hand trailing along the wall for support. Every shadow seemed to hide a threat. Every sound made her jump.
One of them is the mobster, she thought. One of the people I've been trusting, talking to, working with. One of them killed Ricky. One of them tried to kill me.
But which one?
The foyer was empty when she arrived. No one sleeping in the open spaces. No one keeping watch. Everyone had scattered to their hiding spots, too afraid to stay together.
Kaitlyn sank down against a wall, her head still throbbing. She needed to think. Needed to figure this out.
But her thoughts kept circling back to that missing memory. That crucial moment when she'd seen the killer's face, and now it was just... gone.
Concussion, she realized. They hit me hard enough to scramble my memory.
The thought was terrifying. What if she never remembered? What if the identity of the killer was locked away in her damaged brain, inaccessible?
She pulled out her phone, checking the time.
4:47 AM.
Less than two hours until morning. Less than two hours until the announcement.
Kaitlyn closed her eyes, trying to rest, trying to let her brain recover. But every time she started to drift, she saw Ricky's dead eyes staring at nothing, and the smile—that terrible, satisfied smile—hovering just out of reach in her memory.
"Good morning," the game's voice said, cheerful and indifferent. "During the night, several executions have taken place. Ricky Rodriguez has been executed by the mob. He was a civilian. He has been found in the convenience store with his throat cut. Samantha has been executed by the mob. She was a civilian. She has been found on the second floor, stabbed multiple times. And Melinda Rhodes has been executed by the mob. She was a civilian. She has been found tied to a pillar with her throat slit."
The announcement cut through the silence like a knife.
Kaitlyn's eyes snapped open. She was still in the foyer, still slumped against the wall. Pale morning light filtered through the grimy windows.
Samantha.
She hadn't even known she was dead. The mobster had killed during the night.
Footsteps echoed through the corridor. Multiple people, moving quickly.
Kaitlyn forced herself to stand, ignoring the renewed throbbing in her skull. She needed to be alert. Needed to be ready.
Crystal appeared first, her face pale and drawn. She looked like she hadn't slept at all. Behind her came Samantha, then Kasey, then Ailyn, and finally Marley.
Six people.
Six people left alive.
"Kaitlyn!" Crystal rushed over, her expression shifting from relief to concern. "What happened to you? You're bleeding—"
Kaitlyn reached up and touched the back of her head. Her fingers came away sticky with blood.
"I found Ricky," she said, her voice hoarse. "In the convenience store. Someone killed him. And then someone hit me from behind."
"Who?" Samantha demanded. "Who did you see?"
"I don't know," Kaitlyn admitted. "I saw them, but I can't remember. The blow to my head—I think it scrambled my memory."
"Convenient," Marley said quietly.
Everyone turned to look at her.
"What's that supposed to mean?" Kaitlyn asked.
"It means you claim you saw the killer but conveniently can't remember who it was," Marley said. Her voice was flat, emotionless. "Sounds like a pretty good cover story."
"I'm not lying—"
"I didn't say you were lying," Marley interrupted. "I said it was convenient."
"We need to find the bodies," Crystal said, cutting through the tension. "Ricky and Samantha. We need to see what happened."
They found Ricky first, exactly where Kaitlyn had left him. The blood had dried into a dark, sticky pool. His eyes were still open, still staring.
Ailyn turned away and vomited against the wall.
"Jesus Christ," Samantha whispered.
"His throat was cut," Crystal observed, crouching down to examine the body. "Single slash, left to right. Deep. He would have died in seconds."
"Where's Samantha?" Kasey asked.
They found him in one of the empty stores on the second floor. He'd been stabbed multiple times—chest, stomach, throat. The violence was excessive, brutal.
"They wanted to make sure," Crystal said quietly. "No chance of survival."
"Or they enjoyed it," Marley said. Her voice was still flat, but there was something underneath it now. Something dark and bitter.
Kaitlyn studied her face, trying to read her expression. Marley had been different since Samuel's death. Quieter. More withdrawn. But also harder somehow, like something inside her had calcified.
Could it be her? Kaitlyn wondered. Could Marley be the mobster?
But that didn't make sense. Samuel had been a mobster. Why would the mobsters kill one of their own?
Unless...
"We need to talk," Samantha said. "All of us. Right now."
They gathered in the foyer, forming a loose circle. No one sat. No one wanted to be vulnerable.
"Six of us left," Samantha said. "One mobster. We need to figure out who it is before they kill again."
"How?" Ailyn asked. Her voice was small, frightened. "We don't have any evidence. We don't have anything."
"We have logic," Samantha said. "We have patterns. We have behavior."
"We have jack shit," Marley said.
"We have more than that," Samantha insisted. She turned to face Marley directly. "We have the fact that your husband was a mobster."
The silence that followed was absolute.
"What are you saying?" Marley asked slowly.
"I'm saying that mobsters work together," Samantha said. "They coordinate. They plan. And it makes sense that they'd recruit people who are close to each other. People who trust each other."
"You think I'm a mobster because Samuel was?" Marley's voice was rising now, edging toward hysteria. "You think I helped him kill people?"
"I think it's possible," Samantha said. "I think we need to consider it."
"I loved my husband!" Marley screamed. "I watched him jump down an elevator shaft! I heard his body hit the bottom! And you think I was working with him?"
"I think we can't rule it out," Samantha said.
"This is insane," Kaitlyn said. "Marley isn't a mobster. She's been devastated since Samuel died."
"Or she's been pretending to be devastated," Samantha countered. "Think about it. She's been quiet. Withdrawn. Not participating in discussions. What if that's because she's trying to stay under the radar?"
"Or what if it's because her husband just died!" Kaitlyn shouted.
"We don't know that," Samantha said. "We don't know anything for sure."
"I know I'm not a mobster," Marley said. Her voice had gone quiet again, but there was steel underneath it now. "I know I didn't kill anyone. And I know that you're making a terrible mistake."
"Then who is the mobster?" Samantha asked. "If it's not you, then who?"
Marley looked around the circle, her gaze moving from face to face. When she spoke, her voice was cold.
"It could be any of you," she said. "Crystal claims to be the police, but we only have her word for it. Kasey's been working in that computer room, supposedly restoring footage, but what if she's been deleting evidence instead? Ailyn's been quiet and withdrawn—maybe she's hiding something. And Kaitlyn—" She turned to face Kaitlyn directly. "Kaitlyn claims she saw the killer but conveniently can't remember who it was."
"I have a concussion!" Kaitlyn protested.
"So you say," Marley replied. "But how do we know that's true? How do we know you didn't kill Ricky yourself and then hit your own head to create an alibi?"
"That's ridiculous—"
"Is it?" Marley asked. "Is it any more ridiculous than accusing me of being a mobster because my husband was one?"
"She has a point," Kasey said quietly.
Everyone turned to look at her.
"We're all making accusations based on circumstantial evidence," Kasey continued. "Samantha thinks Marley is suspicious because of Samuel. Marley thinks Kaitlyn is suspicious because of her memory loss. But none of us have actual proof."
"Then what do we do?" Ailyn asked.
"We vote," Crystal said. "We make our best guess and we vote."
"And if we're wrong?" Kaitlyn asked. "If we vote out another innocent person?"
"Then we're down to five," Crystal said. "And we try again tomorrow."
"And if we're wrong again?"
"Then we're down to four," Crystal said. "And eventually, we'll get it right. Or the mobster will kill us all."
The brutal honesty of it hung in the air.
"I'm not a mobster," Marley said again. "I swear to God, I'm not a mobster."
"Then prove it," Samantha said.
"How?" Marley demanded. "How am I supposed to prove a negative? How am I supposed to prove I'm not something?"
"You can't," Samantha admitted. "Which is why we have to vote based on probability. And the probability is that you're the mobster."
"Based on what?"
"Based on the fact that Samuel was a mobster," Samantha said. "Based on the fact that you've been acting strange since he died. Based on the fact that someone has to be the mobster, and you're the most likely candidate."
"That's not evidence," Marley said. "That's prejudice."
"It's logic," Samantha countered.
"It's bullshit!" Marley shouted. "You're voting for me because you're scared and you need someone to blame!"
"I'm voting for you because I think you're the mobster," Samantha said calmly.
"Well, I'm voting for you," Marley shot back. "Because I think you're the mobster. You've been pushing for votes, organizing people, making accusations. What if that's because you're trying to control who gets eliminated?"
"That's absurd—"
"Is it?" Marley asked. "You've been very vocal about who should be voted out. Very insistent. What if that's because you're trying to eliminate threats?"
"I'm trying to eliminate the mobster!"
"Or you're trying to eliminate anyone who might figure out it's you!"
The argument was spiraling out of control. Kaitlyn could see it happening, could see the group fracturing, but she didn't know how to stop it.
"We need to calm down," she said. "We need to think rationally—"
"Rationally?" Marley laughed, but there was no humor in it. "There's nothing rational about this situation. We're trapped in an abandoned mall, playing a game where we have to kill each other to survive. Rational went out the window days ago."
"Then what do you suggest?" Crystal asked.
"I suggest we don't vote," Marley said. "I suggest we refuse to participate. Let the mobster kill us if they want, but at least we won't be complicit in murdering innocent people."
"We tried that," Kaitlyn reminded her. "Remember? Five people died in one night."
"Then we're damned either way," Marley said. "Either we vote and kill innocents, or we don't vote and the game kills us. There's no winning. There's only choosing how we die."
The despair in her voice was palpable.
"I'm not ready to give up," Samantha said. "I'm not ready to just lie down and die."
"Then vote for me," Marley said. "Go ahead. Vote for me and watch me die. And when you realize I was innocent, when you realize you made a mistake, remember this moment. Remember that you chose this."
The hours until midnight crawled by with agonizing slowness.
Kaitlyn spent most of them alone, trying desperately to remember what she'd seen in the convenience store. She closed her eyes and focused on the memory, trying to pull it into clarity.
The knife. She remembered the knife.
The blood. She remembered the blood.
The smile. She remembered the smile.
But the face remained frustratingly out of reach.
Was it Marley? she wondered. Was Samantha right?
But something about that didn't feel right. Marley's grief over Samuel had seemed genuine. The way she'd screamed when he jumped, the way she'd sobbed afterward—that hadn't been an act.
Had it?
What if she's just a really good actress? a voice in her head whispered. What if she's been playing you all along?
But the same could be said for anyone. Crystal could be lying about being the police. Kasey could be the mobster, hiding behind her helpful facade. Ailyn could be using her quiet demeanor as camouflage. Even Samantha, with her logical arguments and calm demeanor, could be manipulating them all.
I don't know, Kaitlyn thought. I don't know who to trust.
She found herself back in the computer room, staring at the monitors. Most of them were dark now, the cameras having failed or been destroyed. But a few still worked, showing grainy images of empty corridors and abandoned stores.
On one screen, she could see Marley sitting alone in what looked like a clothing store, her head in her hands. On another, Samantha was pacing back and forth in the foyer, her expression intense and focused. Ailyn was curled up in a corner somewhere, barely visible in the shadows.
And Kasey—
Kaitlyn frowned. Where was Kasey?
She scanned the monitors, looking for her. There—in one of the offices on the second floor. Kasey was sitting at a desk, writing something. Her expression was calm, almost serene.
Too calm, Kaitlyn thought. Everyone else is falling apart, and she's just... calm.
Was that suspicious? Or was Kasey just better at handling stress?
Kaitlyn didn't know. She didn't know anything anymore.
She left the computer room and wandered through the mall, her footsteps echoing in the silence. She passed the convenience store where Ricky had died, passed the empty store where Samantha had been found. The bodies had been moved to the freezer with the others, but the blood remained, dark stains on the floor that no one had bothered to clean.
How many bodies were in that freezer now? Kaitlyn had lost count.
Too many. Far too many.
She found herself in the foyer as the sun began to set, painting the sky outside in shades of orange and red. It should have been beautiful. Instead, it just looked like blood.
One by one, the others arrived. Crystal, looking exhausted. Samantha, looking determined. Kasey, looking calm. Ailyn, looking terrified. And finally, Marley, looking resigned.
"It's almost time," Samantha said.
No one responded.
"We need to vote," Samantha continued. "We need to make a decision."
"I've made my decision," Marley said quietly. "I'm voting for you, Samantha. Because I think you're the mobster."
"And I'm voting for you," Samantha replied. "Because I think you're the mobster."
"What about the rest of you?" Marley asked, looking around the circle. "Who are you voting for?"
Kaitlyn opened her mouth, then closed it again. She didn't know. She genuinely didn't know.
"I'm voting for Marley," Ailyn said quietly. "I'm sorry, but... Samantha's right. The connection to Samuel is too suspicious."
"Ailyn—" Marley started.
"I'm sorry," Ailyn repeated. "But I have to vote for someone. And you're the most likely."
"Most likely based on what?" Marley demanded. "Based on who I married? That's not evidence!"
"It's all we have," Ailyn said.
Marley turned to Crystal. "What about you? Are you voting for me too?"
Crystal hesitated. "I... I don't know. I need to think about it."
"Think fast," Marley said bitterly. "We're running out of time."
Kaitlyn pulled out her phone, staring at the screen. The Murder Game app glowed softly, waiting for her input.
Who do I vote for?
Marley was the obvious choice. The logical choice. Her connection to Samuel made her suspicious, and Samantha's argument had been compelling.
But something about it felt wrong.
What if we're making the same mistake we made with Lexus? Kaitlyn thought. What if we're voting out an innocent person because we're desperate and scared?
But what was the alternative? Vote for someone else? Vote for no one?
The no-vote strategy had failed spectacularly. And voting for someone else would just split the votes, potentially eliminating the wrong person anyway.
There's no good choice, Kaitlyn realized. There's only the least bad choice.
She looked at Marley, really looked at her. Saw the fear in her eyes, the desperation. Saw the way her hands were shaking, the way her breath came in short, sharp gasps.
She's terrified, Kaitlyn thought. She knows we're going to vote for her. She knows she's going to die.
And if she was innocent—if they were wrong—then they were about to murder someone in cold blood.
But if she was the mobster, then voting for her would save them all.
I don't know, Kaitlyn thought. I don't know, I don't know, I don't know.
Her phone buzzed.
THIRTY SECONDS REMAIN FOR VOTING.
"Shit," Crystal whispered.
Kaitlyn's finger hovered over Marley's name. All she had to do was tap it. Just one tap, and her vote would be cast.
Do it, a voice in her head urged. She's the most likely suspect. Vote for her.
But another voice, quieter but more insistent, whispered: What if you're wrong?
Twenty seconds.
Fifteen.
Ten.
Kaitlyn closed her eyes and tapped the screen.
Five.
Four.
Three.
Two.
One.
THE VOTING HAS CONCLUDED.
Silence.
THE RESULTS ARE AS FOLLOWS: MARLEY LOPEZ HAS BEEN ELIMINATED.
Marley's face went white.
"No," she whispered. "No, please—"
MARLEY LOPEZ, YOU HAVE BEEN VOTED OUT. YOU HAVE ONE MINUTE TO COMPLY.
"I'm not a mobster!" Marley screamed. "I'm not a mobster, I swear to God, I'm not—"
But the compulsion was already taking hold. Kaitlyn could see it in her eyes—the moment when her own will was overridden by the game's commands.
Marley's expression shifted from terror to rage.
"You're all going to die," she said, her voice cold and flat. "Every single one of you. The mobster is going to kill you all, and you'll deserve it."
She turned and walked toward the large windows overlooking the parking lot. Her movements were stiff, mechanical, like a puppet on strings.
"Marley, wait—" Kaitlyn started forward, but Crystal grabbed her arm.
"Don't," Crystal said. "You can't stop it."
Marley reached the window and pressed her hands against the glass. For a moment, she just stood there, staring out at the darkening sky.
Then she stepped back and charged.
Her body hit the window with tremendous force. The glass cracked but held, spiderwebbing outward from the point of impact.
Marley stepped back again, blood streaming from a cut on her forehead.
"Marley, stop!" Kaitlyn shouted.
But Marley wasn't listening. Couldn't listen. The compulsion had her completely.
She charged again.
This time, the window shattered.
Marley's body crashed through in a spray of glass and blood, tumbling out into the open air. For a moment, she seemed to hang there, suspended against the orange sky.
Then gravity took hold, and she fell.
The sound of her body hitting the concrete below was sickeningly final.
"Marley Lopez has been eliminated," the game's voice said, cheerful as ever. "Marley was a civilian."
The words hit like a physical blow.
Civilian.
Not a mobster. A civilian.
They'd been wrong.
"No," Samantha whispered. "No, that's not—she had to be—"
"She wasn't," Kaitlyn said. Her voice sounded hollow, distant. "She was innocent. And we killed her."
"We didn't know—"
"We should have known!" Kaitlyn shouted. "We should have been sure! We should have had evidence, not just—not just suspicion and fear!"
"We did what we had to do," Samantha said, but her voice wavered.
"We murdered an innocent person," Kaitlyn said. "That's what we did. We murdered her."
The silence that followed was broken only by the sound of Ailyn crying.
They didn't move Marley's body.
No one wanted to go outside, to cross the boundary and risk execution. So Marley lay where she'd fallen, broken and bleeding on the concrete, visible through the shattered window.
A reminder of their mistake.
Kaitlyn sat in the foyer, staring at nothing. Around her, the others had scattered to their hiding spots, too afraid to stay together, too afraid to be alone.
Five people left.
Five people, and one of them was a mobster.
It's not Marley, Kaitlyn thought. We know that now. So who is it?
Samantha had been wrong about Marley. Did that make her suspicious? Or just human?
Crystal claimed to be the police, but they only had her word for it. What if she'd been lying all along?
Kasey had been calm throughout everything. Too calm. Was that because she was the mobster, or just because she handled stress better than the others?
Ailyn had been quiet and withdrawn. Was she hiding something, or just traumatized?
And Kaitlyn herself—she'd seen the killer's face but couldn't remember it. Was that really because of a concussion, or was her subconscious protecting her from a truth she didn't want to face?
What if I'm the mobster? she thought suddenly. What if I killed Ricky and Samantha and then hit myself to create an alibi? What if my memory loss is real, but it's because I can't face what I've done?
The thought was terrifying. Not because she believed it, but because she couldn't completely rule it out.
I'm not a mobster, she told herself firmly. I know I'm not. I remember my role. Civilian. I'm a civilian.
But Marley had been a civilian too. And they'd voted her out anyway.
Kaitlyn pulled out her phone, staring at the screen.
ROLE: CIVILIAN
The words should have been reassuring. Instead, they just made her feel more helpless.
She thought about the people who'd died. Charity, Tamika, Peter, Sean, J Mont, Melinda (twice), Jace, Samuel, Charlotte, Sam, Sev, Lexus, Travis, Crystal (wait, no, Crystal was still alive), Ricky, Samantha, Marley.
Eighteen people dead.
Eighteen people who'd boarded that bus expecting an urban exploration experience and instead found themselves trapped in a nightmare.
And for what? What was the point of all this death?
The game, Kaitlyn thought. Someone created this game. Someone programmed it, set it up, brought us here. Someone wanted this to happen.
But who? And why?
She thought about the mysterious figure in the security footage, the girl from the photo with the scratched-out face. Was she the one behind this? Was she watching them right now, enjoying their suffering?
Or was she just another victim, someone who'd died before the game even started?
Kaitlyn didn't know. She was so tired of not knowing.
She closed her eyes, trying to rest, but sleep wouldn't come. Every time she started to drift, she saw Marley's face—the terror, the rage, the resignation. Saw her charging at the window, saw her body falling, saw her lying broken on the concrete.
We killed her, Kaitlyn thought. We voted her out, and she died, and it was our fault.
Not the game's fault. Not the mobster's fault.
Our fault.
The weight of that guilt was crushing.
Kaitlyn must have dozed off eventually, because she woke to the sound of footsteps.
She opened her eyes to find Kasey standing over her, silhouetted against the pale morning light.
"It's almost dawn," Kasey said quietly. "We should probably gather. Wait for the announcement."
Kaitlyn nodded, pushing herself to her feet. Her head still ached, but the throbbing had dulled to a manageable level.
They walked to the foyer together in silence. Crystal was already there, looking like she hadn't slept at all. Samantha arrived a few minutes later, her expression haunted. Ailyn came last, her eyes red and swollen from crying.
Five people.
Five people left alive.
They stood in a loose circle, not looking at each other, waiting for the inevitable announcement.
The sun rose slowly, painting the sky in shades of pink and gold. It should have been beautiful. Instead, it just felt like a countdown.
"Good morning!" the cheerful voice said. "During the night, no one was executed."
The words took a moment to register.
"What?" Samantha said. "No one?"
"The mobsters chose not to execute anyone," the voice continued. "All players survived the night."
"Why?" Crystal asked. "Why would they—"
"Because they're playing with us," Kaitlyn said quietly. "They want us to suffer. Want us to tear ourselves apart."
"Or because they're scared," Samantha said. "Maybe they know we're close to figuring out who they are."
"Or maybe they just wanted to see what we'd do," Kasey said. "Wanted to see if we'd turn on each other without any new deaths to investigate."
"Well, we did," Ailyn said bitterly. "We voted out Marley. An innocent person. And the mobster didn't even have to do anything."
The guilt in her voice was palpable.
"We made a mistake," Samantha said. "But we can't let that paralyze us. We need to keep trying—"
"Keep trying to what?" Ailyn demanded. "Keep voting out innocent people? Keep murdering each other while the real mobster watches and laughs?"
"We don't have a choice—"
"We always have a choice!" Ailyn shouted. "We can choose to stop! We can choose to refuse to play!"
"And then we all die," Samantha said. "Is that what you want?"
"Maybe," Ailyn said quietly. "Maybe that would be better than this."
The despair in her voice was heartbreaking.
Kaitlyn looked around at the faces of the survivors. Crystal, exhausted and defeated. Samantha, determined but shaken. Kasey, calm but distant. Ailyn, broken and hopeless.
And herself—traumatized, confused, drowning in guilt.
This is what the game wanted, she realized. This is the point. Not just to kill us, but to destroy us. To make us destroy each other.
And it was working.
"We need to figure out who the mobster is," Kaitlyn said. "Before tonight. Before they kill again."
"How?" Crystal asked. "We don't have any evidence. We don't have anything."
"We have each other," Kaitlyn said. "We have our observations, our instincts. We have—"
"We have nothing," Ailyn interrupted. "We had all that before, and we still voted out an innocent person."
"Then we'll be more careful this time," Kaitlyn said. "We'll think harder, look closer—"
"It won't matter," Ailyn said. "We're going to keep making mistakes until we're all dead. That's how this ends. That's the only way this can end."
"No," Kaitlyn said firmly. "No, we can survive this. We can figure it out. We just need to—"
"To what?" Ailyn asked. "To trust each other? We can't trust each other. One of us is a murderer. One of us has been lying to us from the beginning. How are we supposed to trust anyone?"
Kaitlyn didn't have an answer.
Because Ailyn was right.
They couldn't trust each other. Not really. Not when one of them was a mobster, hiding behind a mask of innocence.
But which one?
Kaitlyn looked at each of them in turn, trying to see past the facades, trying to glimpse the truth underneath.
Crystal, who claimed to be the police but had no way to prove it.
Samantha, who'd been so certain about Marley and had been so terribly wrong.
Kasey, who'd been helpful and supportive but also strangely calm throughout everything.
Ailyn, who'd been quiet and withdrawn, agreeing with accusations rather than making her own.
One of them was lying.
One of them was the mobster.
And Kaitlyn had no idea which one.
The sun continued to rise, indifferent to their suffering. The mall remained silent except for the distant drip of water and the occasional creak of settling metal.
Somewhere in the building, Marley's body lay broken on the concrete, a testament to their failure.
And somewhere among the five survivors, a mobster smiled and waited for night to fall again.
The day passed in a haze of paranoia and fear.
No one wanted to be alone, but no one wanted to be together either. They drifted through the mall like ghosts, avoiding each other, lost in their own thoughts.
Kaitlyn found herself back in the computer room, staring at the monitors. Most of them were still dark, but a few showed grainy images of the others.
Samantha, pacing in the foyer.
Crystal, sitting alone in an empty store, her head in her hands.
Ailyn, curled up in a corner somewhere, barely moving.
And Kasey—
Kaitlyn frowned. Kasey was in one of the offices, writing something again. Her expression was calm, focused.
What is she writing? Kaitlyn wondered.
She watched for a few more minutes, but Kasey didn't look up, didn't stop writing. Just kept going, page after page, her hand moving steadily across the paper.
Is that suspicious? Kaitlyn thought. Or is she just coping in her own way?
She didn't know. She didn't know anything anymore.
Kaitlyn left the computer room and wandered through the mall, her footsteps echoing in the silence. She passed the convenience store, passed the empty stores, passed the shattered window where Marley had fallen.
She couldn't bring herself to look outside. Couldn't bear to see Marley's body lying there.
We killed her, she thought again. We voted her out, and she died, and it was our fault.
The guilt was overwhelming.
She found herself in the foyer as the sun began to set, painting the sky in shades of orange and red. Blood colors. Death colors.
One by one, the others arrived. Crystal, looking even more exhausted than before. Samantha, looking grim and determined. Kasey, looking calm. Ailyn, looking hollow.
"It's almost time," Samantha said.
No one responded.
"We need to vote," Samantha continued. "We need to make a decision."
"Another decision," Ailyn said bitterly. "Another chance to kill an innocent person."
"We don't have a choice—"
"Stop saying that!" Ailyn shouted. "We always have a choice! We can choose to stop playing this game!"
"And then we all die," Samantha said.
"Maybe that would be better," Ailyn replied.
The silence that followed was heavy with despair.
Kaitlyn pulled out her phone, staring at the screen. The Murder Game app glowed softly, waiting for her input.
Who do I vote for?
She had no idea.
No evidence. No proof. Just suspicion and fear and the terrible certainty that whoever they voted for would probably be innocent.
Just like Lexus.
Just like Marley.
I can't do this, Kaitlyn thought. I can't vote for someone else. I can't be responsible for another death.
But what was the alternative?
The no-vote strategy had failed. And if she didn't vote, someone else would be eliminated anyway.
There's no good choice, she thought. There's only the least bad choice.
But what was the least bad choice?
Her phone buzzed.
THIRTY SECONDS REMAIN FOR VOTING.
Kaitlyn's finger hovered over the screen, trembling.
I don't know, she thought desperately. I don't know who to vote for.
Twenty seconds.
Fifteen.
Ten.
She closed her eyes and tapped a name at random.
Five.
Four.
Three.
Two.
One.
THE VOTING HAS CONCLUDED.
Kaitlyn opened her eyes, her heart pounding.
THE RESULTS ARE AS FOLLOWS: THE VOTES ARE TIED. NO ONE HAS BEEN ELIMINATED.
Relief flooded through her, so intense it was almost painful.
No one died, she thought. We didn't kill anyone.
But the relief was short-lived.
Because as the sun set and darkness fell over the mall, Kaitlyn realized the truth.
They hadn't eliminated the mobster.
Which meant the mobster was still out there.
Still hunting.
Still killing.
And tonight, someone else would die.
The night phase began, and the five survivors scattered to their hiding spots, each one alone, each one terrified.
Kaitlyn found herself in an empty store, her back against the wall, watching the entrance.
One of them is the mobster, she thought. One of the four people I just saw. One of them is going to kill someone tonight.
But which one?
And who would they kill?
The questions circled endlessly in her mind as the hours crawled by.
Somewhere in the darkness, a mobster moved through the corridors, silent and deadly.
Somewhere in the darkness, someone was about to die.
And Kaitlyn had no idea how to stop it.
She closed her eyes, trying to rest, but sleep wouldn't come.
All she could see was Marley's face.
All she could hear was Marley's voice: You're all going to die. Every single one of you.
And Kaitlyn was starting to think she was right.
Eliminated:
Marley Lopez (Civilian) (Voted out wrongly; charged at window and fell to concrete)
Samantha Hamilton (Civilian) (Executed by Kasey during night)
Hamilton (Civilian) (Executed by Kasey during night)

